The Things We Think We Know

By

Written in June 2026.

I’ve been a lot of things in this life.

A writer.

A marathoner.

A divorced mother.

A woman who spent years calling herself a feminist while somehow never quite managing to grab hold of her own voice and use it with any real conviction.

The younger of two girls raised by a small town mechanic.

The niece of a man who disappeared from our family for years and returned later with a husband, forcing everyone to confront a truth they didn’t know how to hold at first.

And if you had asked me at any point over the last forty years what I thought about sexuality, I would have shrugged.

I don’t care.

That was always my answer.

Not because I was surrounded by diversity or because I’d done any meaningful work examining my beliefs. Mostly because I grew up in places where everyone looked alike, thought alike, loved alike, and then I became busy living my own life.

I didn’t know many people who weren’t straight.

Not by design.

Just by circumstance.

So I carried around this comfortable belief that I was accepting because I’d never felt any reason not to be.

Life has a funny way of testing theories.

I’ve spent years convinced I was a mediocre mother.

Some days, worse than mediocre.

I divorced their father—a genuinely good man—and married someone who could not have been more different if I had ordered him from a catalog titled Poor Decisions and Unresolved Trauma.

At the time, I thought I was giving my boys a glimpse of something different.

Strength.

Masculinity.

A different kind of role model.

Instead, I spent years trapped inside my own chaos.

Years surviving PTSD that wasn’t even mine.

Years writing blog posts about healing while simultaneously bleeding all over the floor of my own life.

The boys paid for more of that than they ever should have.

Children always do.

Somewhere along the way, I convinced myself my oldest had simply opted out of relationships altogether.

I had theories.

Lots of them.

Maybe he wasn’t interested.

Maybe he was shy.

Maybe I’d done such a spectacular job demonstrating the dangers of love that he’d decided to skip the whole thing.

I never said that out loud, but I thought it.

I’ve also suspected for years that one of my kids might eventually tell me they were gay.

And if I’m being completely honest—and honesty is kind of the whole point here—I carried a small private sadness about that possibility.

Not because I thought there was anything wrong with it.

Because I imagined the grandchildren who might never exist.

Because I imagined another branch of the family tree ending with me.

Because generational trauma has a remarkable way of disguising itself as concern for the future.

Ugly thoughts can still be honest thoughts.

For the last three years, while I was consumed by one of the hardest periods of my life, my oldest child was carrying something far heavier than I realized.

Silently.

Stoically.

In what I always called his “boy way.”

The irony of that phrase is not lost on me now.

Then, slowly, he started expressing himself.

Tiny things at first.

Small shifts.

Conversations that felt like they were circling something larger.

And I became convinced he was about to tell me he was gay.

I was ready for that conversation.

Or at least I thought I was.

Instead, in half-finished sentences and cautious words, he told me he was transitioning.

And my brain promptly left the chat.

Not because I was angry.

Not because I loved him less.

Not because I rejected him.

Because suddenly every assumption I’d ever made about myself was standing in front of me demanding an explanation.

I thought I was open-minded.

I thought I was accepting.

I thought I understood what it meant to let people be who they are.

Then the universe handed me someone I loved more than my own life and asked:

Okay. Show me.

It’s one thing to support an idea.

It’s another thing entirely when that idea becomes your child.

For a month, I unraveled quietly.

I questioned everything.

I examined memories.

Childhood bedrooms littered with cars.

Personality traits like lining them up in rows.

Things I had dismissed.

Things I had misunderstood.

Things I should have seen.

And somewhere in that process, something unexpected happened.

The fear left.

Not all at once.

But steadily.

What replaced it was curiosity.

Then understanding.

Then pride.

And perhaps most surprisingly, the further I’ve traveled into understanding this, the less surprised I am.

Because the truth is, I am probably the manliest woman I know.

Not in some bumper-sticker, performative sense.

I mean genuinely.

I have always been more comfortable carrying the couch than asking someone else to carry it for me.

I have spent most of my life solving problems, suppressing tears, and white-knuckling my way through things that probably deserved softer handling.

I’ve always been more comfortable around men.

I don’t mean that as a cool-girl confession or some tired little not like other girls anthem. God spare us all.

I just mean that, for most of my life, I didn’t think much about it.

If there was a table of men talking, I sat there.

If there was a group problem to solve, I wandered toward the people already taking it apart.

If there was heavy furniture, machinery, logistics, business, conflict, weather, dirt, road trips, blunt jokes, or silence that didn’t require emotional translation, I fit.

Or I thought I did.

Then one day, a woman called me out for it.

I was sitting with the men instead of the wives, and she looked at me and said:

“I know you think you are one of them, but you belong over here with us.”

There are sentences that don’t seem important when they land, but years later you realize they left a bruise.

At the time, I laughed it off.

Because what else do you do when someone draws a circle around your body and tells you which side of the room you’re allowed to stand in?

But I remember it.

I remember the sting of being corrected.

Not because I wanted to be a man.

Not exactly.

Because I had never considered that my comfort had become someone else’s violation of order.

I had never thought of myself as performing anything.

I was just existing in the place that felt easiest.

And suddenly there was a woman telling me I had wandered out of my assigned seat.

For years, that part of me felt natural.

Then somewhere along the way, I started running from her.

Maybe because I thought she was too much.

Too blunt.

Too intimidating.

Too difficult to fit inside the shape of what a woman was supposed to be.

Not because she’s wiser.

So I spent the better part of a decade experimenting with her opposite.

I bought the dresses.

I softened the edges.

I tried femininity on the way someone tries on a coat in a department store, turning sideways in the mirror and wondering if it looks like it belongs to them.

I wrote books.

I made art.

I explored softness and romance and vulnerability in places where I could grant myself permission to feel things I never allowed myself in real life.

At the time I would have called it growth.

Later, I called it failure.

Now I think it was probably exploration.

After everything that has happened these past few years—the hardest years of my marriage, the trauma, the rebuilding, the brutal inventory of who I am and who I am not—I found myself handing the keys back to the woman I started as.

Not because she was better.

Because she was mine.

The strongest version of myself was never the most feminine one.

It was the most authentic one.

And that’s where this whole thing becomes unexpectedly beautiful.

Because I don’t know where my child’s journey ends.

I don’t know who they’ll become.

I don’t know what parts they’ll keep and what parts they’ll leave behind.

And I don’t want them to feel trapped by today’s answers any more than I wanted to be trapped by mine.

Maybe this is forever.

Maybe it isn’t.

Maybe there are turns ahead neither of us can see yet.

The older I get, the less interested I am in certainty.

Life has humbled me out of most of it.

What I know is this:

Identity is not a prison sentence.

It is not a contract signed in blood.

It is not something you owe the world once you’ve spoken it aloud.

It is a conversation with yourself that lasts your entire life.

Had I grown up in a different era, with different language and different frameworks, would I have made different choices?

Honestly, maybe.

I don’t know.

That isn’t a rejection of who I am.

It’s an acknowledgment that my children inherited a world I did not.

They have language for experiences we didn’t have language for.

They have frameworks that simply did not exist when I was young.

Some of that confuses me.

Some of it impresses me.

Most of it just reminds me how quickly the world changes.

For years I thought I wasn’t enough of anything.

Not feminist enough.

Not artistic enough.

Not brave enough.

Not bold enough.

Not authentic enough.

But those weren’t truths.

They were misunderstandings.

I wasn’t failing at being a woman.

I was simply being a different kind of woman than the ones I compared myself against.

Whole the entire time.

Completely myself.

And maybe that’s what I want my child to know more than anything.

Not that I understand every answer.

Not that I’ll never get things wrong.

Not that I won’t occasionally stumble over language, assumptions, or my own blind spots.

But that there is no finish line where they finally become acceptable.

There is no perfect version waiting at the end of this.

There is only the lifelong work of becoming more honestly yourself.

I hope the mother I am now is better than the mother I was ten years ago.

I think she is.

Because she’s been broken more times.

Because she’s been wrong more times.

Because she’s learned that loving someone is not the same thing as understanding them.

And because she finally knows those are two very different gifts.

Whatever this next chapter becomes, I am grateful I’ve lived through everything that brought me here.

I hope all of it—the mistakes, the grief, the rebuilding, the years spent becoming myself—makes me a better mother for what comes next.

However this unfolds, I hope I am worthy of the trust it took to tell me.

Posted In ,

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Rose CARLSON

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading